America Can’t Bomb Iran Out of Making a Nuclear Weapon

Opinion|America Can’t Bomb Iran Out of Making a Nuclear Weapon

After more than four decades of effort, Iran was closer than ever to having the capability to assemble a nuclear weapon rapidly. Then on Friday, Israel launched a massive attack on the country and its nuclear facilities.

Now President Trump is reportedly considering whether to join that war. On Tuesday he met with his national security team to debate airstrikes, after using social media to call for Iran’s “unconditional surrender!” On Wednesday he declined to tell reporters whether he would involve the U.S. military in Israel’s campaign. “I may do it,” he said. “I may not do it. I mean, nobody knows what I’m going to do.”

Israel has already inflicted extensive damage. According to Rafael Grossi, the director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency, Israel has destroyed facilities at Isfahan, a major nuclear research center, and might have disabled Iran’s largest enrichment plant, an underground installation at Natanz. However, it does not appear to have damaged a second underground enrichment plant, Fordo, which is probably too deeply buried for Israel to destroy on its own. It would need help from the United States, which possesses a bunker buster bomb that was designed to reach the facility, as well as planes big enough to carry the 30,000-pound behemoth of a weapon.

In deciding whether to conduct an attack, Mr. Trump should judge the efficacy of any military action by the same standards against which he previously assessed diplomacy.

During his first administration, Mr. Trump criticized the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, better known as the Iran nuclear deal, because, he claimed, it imposed limitations on Tehran’s nuclear program for just a few years. In reality, the deal’s various restrictions on Iran’s stockpile of enriched uranium and its enrichment activities were to last for 10 or 15 years.

Bombing Fordo — and whatever might come after — might not set back Iran’s enrichment efforts by nearly as long. There are hundreds or more likely thousands of scientists and technicians employed in Iran’s enrichment program. Israel’s killing of leading scientists is intended to set back this effort, but Iran could almost certainly reconstitute its program within 10 or 15 years, even if the United States and Israel succeeded in destroying Fordo and Iran’s stockpiles of enriched uranium and centrifuge components.